TODAY IN NUMBERS
SCIENCE · SATIRE · PREFERENCE LITERALISM

AI-Designed Enzyme Assembles a Drug Molecule by Ignoring Almost Everything in the Flask

Sixty-seven designs were tested and four worked. The best converted 79 per cent of a bulky amine while declining to react with the water around it.

Editorial cartoon illustration: A biochemist in a lab coat sits at a bench peering into a tall glass beaker filled almost to the brim with clear water, in which a single tiny speck floats. Two colleagues stand behind her with folded arms, watching. She is holding an enormous pair of blacksmith's tongs, poised to pick the speck out.
Editorial illustration by The Questionable Times. Based on the verified event; scene is illustrative.

A generative model has designed working enzymes for a difficult step in the manufacture of a medicine, in what its authors present as a proof of concept for building biological catalysts to order.

The model, RFD4-Proteina, was developed at the Institute for Protein Design at the University of Washington in collaboration with NVIDIA, combining the institute's RosettaFold Diffusion line with NVIDIA's Proteina-Complexa. It is open source under a BSD-3 licence.

Its development was led by David Baker, the institute's director and a professor of biochemistry at the University of Washington School of Medicine, a Howard Hughes Medical Institute investigator and a 2024 Nobel laureate in chemistry.

The model was applied to enzyme design at the Manchester Institute of Biotechnology by a team including its director, Professor Anthony Green, Dr Henry Jones and Dr Zefei Xu. The underlying work is a preprint, "Biomolecular design through latent reasoning with RFD4-Proteina", by Nathaniel Corley and colleagues, written up for Phys.org by the University of Manchester.

On computational benchmarks the model's design success rates were five to ten times higher than previous models, and it generated candidates five to ten times faster. It can also devote more computation to harder problems.

The target was an amide-bond-forming step in the synthesis of lenacapavir, a drug used to prevent HIV infection. The step requires a bulky chiral amine to be joined selectively, favouring one of its two mirror-image forms.

Of 67 designs selected for experimental testing, four showed clear activity. The best converted 79 per cent of the amine into the desired amide product, and strongly favoured the S-enantiomer, as the synthesis requires.

The enzyme must also suppress a competing reaction with water, which is present in large excess.

"The initial results are spectacular and show how these advanced models can rapidly deliver new biocatalysts," Green said. Baker said: "RFD4-Proteina will open the door to new solutions in medicine, sustainability, materials and biotechnology."

It is worth dwelling on what the successful enzyme is being praised for. The vessel contains a great deal of water and a small quantity of the molecule the chemists want joined. The enzyme's accomplishment is to work on the small quantity.

Stated as a preference, it is the most selective preference in industrial chemistry. The enzyme is surrounded by an overwhelming majority of a reactive substance and declines to engage with any of it.

This newspaper notes that the figure of merit here is not speed, nor yield, but refusal. Four designs out of sixty-seven were able to ignore the solvent. The other sixty-three are recorded as inactive.

The Department of Unnecessary Research has reviewed the ranking and finds it consistent throughout. The best enzyme is the one that notices the least.

Chemistry has therefore acquired a design brief it can hand straight to a generative model. Build something that sits in water and attends to almost nothing.

DESIGNS TESTED AGAINST DESIGNS THAT WORKEDQUESTIONABLE ANALYTICS
100Selected for testing
6Showed clear activity
Normalised 0-100 for display: 67 designs were selected for experimental testing and four showed clear activity.
THE BORING FACT

Researchers at the Manchester Institute of Biotechnology used RFD4-Proteina, a generative protein-design model from the Institute for Protein Design and NVIDIA, to design enzymes for an amide-bond-forming step in the synthesis of the HIV prevention drug lenacapavir. Of 67 designs tested experimentally, four showed clear activity, and the best converted 79 per cent of a bulky chiral amine into the desired product.

Source: Phys.org
OUR PROFESSIONAL CONCLUSION

Because the enzyme's hard task is to join a scarce molecule while declining to react with the water it is dissolved in, the measure of a good designed enzyme becomes how little of its surroundings it notices.

REALITY CHECK · PREFERENCE LITERALISM

Unfortunately, there's a small problem.

Suppressing hydrolysis is one requirement among several; the inactive designs failed for many reasons rather than because they reacted with the solvent, and selectivity is a property of an active site, not a form of inattention. The piece reads chemical selectivity as a personality trait.

THE BS DETECTOR

Where did reality end?

Tap the paragraph where this story stopped being true. Then see where everyone else bailed.

 

READER CREDULITY METER

Did you believe this story before the twist?

Be the first reader to answer.