TODAY IN NUMBERS
POLITICS · SATIRE · INTERVAL ARITHMETIC

Drivers Get Five Minutes to Decide Whether to Park and Ten Minutes to Leave, Which Is Fifteen Minutes of Not Parking

The government's Private Parking Code of Practice, seven years in the making, sets guaranteed grace periods, a £20 appeal cap and a freeze on the £100 maximum charge. Some 17 million private tickets were issued last year.

Editorial cartoon illustration: A driver sits in a car just inside the entrance of a small city car park with the window down, looking out at the empty bays. A parking attendant in a high-visibility jacket stands a few metres away with his hands behind his back, waiting, while two other drivers park normally in the background and walk off toward the street. The seated driver holds a small hourglass up to the light.
Editorial illustration by The Questionable Times. Based on the verified event; scene is illustrative.

Drivers using private car parks in England, Scotland and Wales will be given a guaranteed five-minute period in which to decide whether to park, and a ten-minute window in which to leave without facing a penalty, under new rules set out by the government.

The code also requires charges to be cancelled where the driver could not control the outcome, including vehicle breakdowns in car parks, broken ticket machines and medical emergencies, and for honest mistakes such as stopping to check directions.

Charges on appeal will be capped at £20 for slip-ups including forgetting a parking permit, entering the wrong vehicle registration, or forgetting to confirm the registration in the machine when parking. The maximum parking charge is frozen at £100, the same limit as the current private parking Code of Practice.

Private car parks are governed separately from council-owned car parks and streets, and more tickets are now being issued at private sites than ever recorded. According to RAC analysis of government data, some 17 million private parking tickets were issued in 2025-26, a 17 per cent increase on the year before. With each charge worth up to £100, the data suggests drivers could collectively face private parking charges worth more than £4.6m each day.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham said: "Being a few minutes late back to your car or typing one digit of your number plate wrong shouldn't end with a hefty fine landing on your doormat." He added that such charges left "people feeling ripped off and out of pocket".

Angela Rayner, the Communities and Housing Secretary, told BBC Breakfast that parking "shouldn't be a way of making money". Of the industry's existing arrangements she said: "We're calling time on it. They have regulated themselves and they have their appeals process but we're giving it more meat now." She said the current level of fine was a "proportionate response to when people don't follow the rules".

The government's code has been seven years in the making. An act of Parliament was passed in 2019 to create one; the resulting code was withdrawn in 2022, which the RAC attributes to resistance from the private parking industry. The industry's own Code of Practice, written by the British Parking Association and the International Parking Community, was introduced in 2024 and updated last year after a review.

Derek Millard-Smith of the British Parking Association said the group welcomed the changes because they would "increase trust", and defended the level of charges. "We know dog fouling, rail fare dodging, littering - all those levels are around £100 or more because that is a level that is deemed sufficient to change behaviours," he said.

Motoring groups welcomed the rules without being satisfied by them. Jack Cousens, head of roads policy at the AA, said: "There is still a huge amount of work to do, such as tackling the scourge of debt recovery fees," adding: "Ultimately, we need to stop charges being issued in the first place, especially where the driver has done nothing wrong." The RAC's head of policy, Simon Williams, called for debt recovery fees to be banned and for the industry-run appeals bodies to be replaced by a single independent one.

Operators who do not comply risk losing access to DVLA data, which makes it harder to pursue a car's owner even if a charge is issued. The government says it will consult on debt recovery fees and on other recommendations from the Competition and Markets Authority.

The two headline periods repay closer attention, because they are not the same period. One is five minutes to decide whether to park. The other is ten minutes to leave. Read together, the code establishes fifteen minutes during which a vehicle is on private land and is not, in any enforceable sense, parked.

This is a new category and the code does not name it. The motorist is inside the car park, inside the rules, and generating no liability. The first five minutes are spent deciding. The last ten are spent leaving. At no point in the sequence is anyone required to park.

The arithmetic is not difficult. A driver who declines to park and departs has used the full fifteen-minute entitlement and owes nothing. A driver who then re-enters begins a fresh five minutes of deciding. The code places no limit on how many times a motorist may consider a car park.

Our analysts note that this leaves the operators in an unusual position. They have secured a frozen £100 maximum and a £20 appeal cap, and have accepted in exchange that parking is now formally the thing which happens between minute five and the moment of departure. The interval in between belongs to the driver.

The Department of Unnecessary Research has written to the British Parking Association for guidance on the one question the code leaves open. If every arrival is spent deciding and every departure is spent leaving, at what point does a car park acquire a customer.

MINUTES THE NEW CODE GUARANTEESQUESTIONABLE ANALYTICS
5Deciding whether to park
10Leaving without penalty
15Combined
Minutes allowed by the new code, plotted on a 0-100 display scale. The five- and ten-minute figures are the code's own; the combined figure is their sum.
THE BORING FACT

Under new private parking rules for England, Scotland and Wales, drivers get a guaranteed five-minute period to decide whether to park and a ten-minute window to leave without a penalty, charges on appeal are capped at £20 for specified slip-ups, and the maximum parking charge is frozen at £100.

Source: BBC News
OUR PROFESSIONAL CONCLUSION

Because the code guarantees five minutes to decide whether to park and ten minutes to leave, it creates a fifteen-minute interval in which a car is in a car park without parking, and nothing in the rules obliges a motorist ever to park at all.

REALITY CHECK · INTERVAL ARITHMETIC

Unfortunately, there's a small problem.

The consideration and grace periods exist so that short, unavoidable stops are not charged; they describe entering and leaving, not a right to occupy a bay. A parking charge arises from parking without paying, so stringing the two windows together does not create a free entitlement.

THE BS DETECTOR

Where did reality end?

Tap the paragraph where this story stopped being true. Then see where everyone else bailed.

 

READER CREDULITY METER

Did you believe this story before the twist?

Be the first reader to answer.