TODAY IN NUMBERS
WORLD · SATIRE · CATEGORY ERROR

France Lends Mexico an Aztec Codex After 186 Years, on Condition That Mexico Lends France a Different Aztec Codex

The Codex Azcatitlan goes on show in Mexico City for the first time since it left the country. The Codex Boturini travels the other way, leaving the total number of codices in each country unchanged.

Editorial cartoon illustration: Two curators in white gloves pass each other on an airport tarmac, each carrying a flat wooden crate carefully in both arms, one walking towards a French aircraft and one walking away from it. Behind them a Mexican museum guard holds a door open with elaborate courtesy. A stray dog trots alongside the curators carrying a rolled-up bundle of its own.
Editorial illustration by The Questionable Times. Based on the verified event; scene is illustrative.

A centuries-old manuscript telling the story of the Aztec civilisation in pictograms is going on display in Mexico for the first time in 186 years.

The document, known as the Codex Azcatitlan, has been held in France's Bibliotheque Nationale since 1898, and had already spent decades outside Mexico before that. It is thought to have been drawn in the 16th Century, a few years after the arrival of the Spanish conquistadors in what is now Mexico, and is widely considered one of the most valuable and insightful tellings of Aztec history.

Among the scenes it depicts are the arrival of Hernan Cortes and the defence of Tenochtitlan.

France has lent the codex to Mexico to mark 200 years of Franco-Mexican relations. It will be exhibited at the National Museum of Anthropology in Mexico City from Thursday.

In return, Mexico has agreed to lend another priceless document, the Codex Boturini, to France for display there. Its pictograms narrate the migration of the Aztecs, also known as the Mexica, from their ancestral homeland to the shores of Lake Texcoco, where they built Tenochtitlan.

The temporary exchange of the two codices was agreed by Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum and her French counterpart, Emmanuel Macron, during a visit by the latter to Mexico last year.

The arrangement sits within a much longer campaign. Mexico has lobbied for years for the return of historical artefacts taken from the country in past centuries, and according to its ministry of foreign relations more than 2,000 objects were successfully repatriated last year.

For visitors to the National Museum of Anthropology, the practical result is straightforward: a document that has not been seen in Mexico for 186 years will be in a case in Mexico City.

It is worth being precise about the accounting, however. The Codex Azcatitlan arrives in Mexico. The Codex Boturini leaves it. At the close of business, the National Museum of Anthropology holds exactly as many codices as it held on Wednesday.

The same is true in Paris, where the Bibliotheque Nationale gives up one manuscript and receives one manuscript. Under any recognised standard of accounting, both institutions have stayed precisely the same size.

This is not a repatriation. It is a rotation. The Questionable Times notes approvingly that in codices, as in trade, the Franco-Mexican relationship is now perfectly balanced at 200 years.

The Department of Unnecessary Research recommends extending the principle to the rest of the caseload. Each of the 2,000-odd objects repatriated last year could be matched by an object dispatched in the other direction, holding the total quantity of history in each country constant while every individual claim is satisfied.

Both loans are described as temporary, and the Department looks forward to the return leg. Mexico would finish the process with exactly as many artefacts as it started with, which is the only outcome both governments could sign.

CODICES HELD, BEFORE AND AFTERQUESTIONABLE ANALYTICS
50Mexico before
50Mexico after
50France before
50France after
Illustrative newsroom graphic. One codex arrives and one departs in each country, so the totals are unchanged; the bars are equal because the exchange is.
THE BORING FACT

The Codex Azcatitlan, held in France's Bibliotheque Nationale since 1898, goes on display at Mexico's National Museum of Anthropology for the first time in 186 years. In return, Mexico is lending the Codex Boturini to France.

Source: BBC News
OUR PROFESSIONAL CONCLUSION

Because each country sends one codex and receives one codex, the exchange satisfies a repatriation claim while leaving the number of codices in each country exactly as it was.

REALITY CHECK · CATEGORY ERROR

Unfortunately, there's a small problem.

A loan is not a restitution claim and was never presented as one: the point is that a document unavailable in Mexico since the 1840s can now be seen there, and that both countries are marking 200 years of relations. Counting objects rather than access is the error.

THE BS DETECTOR

Where did reality end?

Tap the paragraph where this story stopped being true. Then see where everyone else bailed.

 

READER CREDULITY METER

Did you believe this story before the twist?

Be the first reader to answer.