TODAY IN NUMBERS
POLITICS · SATIRE · CATEGORY ERROR

India's Solar Farming Capacity Should Pass Five Gigawatts in Three to Four Years, a Figure the Ministry Says Is Difficult to Estimate

The Union Ministry of New and Renewable Energy expects agrivoltaic capacity above 5GW, subject to how quickly states notify feed-in tariffs. The other stated condition is enthusiasm.

Editorial cartoon illustration: A senior civil servant in a plain dark suit stands at a lectern in a bright Delhi conference room, speaking to a seated row of reporters who are holding up small voice recorders. Through tall windows behind him is a field of low solar panels with rows of green crops growing in the gaps between them. On the lectern beside him sits a large brass balance scale with both pans empty, and he rests one hand on it as he talks.
Editorial illustration by The Questionable Times. Based on the verified event; scene is illustrative.

India's agrivoltaic capacity could rise above five gigawatts within the next three to four years, the senior civil servant at the Union Ministry of New and Renewable Energy has said, with the outcome depending on how quickly individual states act.

Santosh Kumar Sarangi, Secretary at the ministry, gave the figure to reporters at a briefing ahead of the seventh Agrivoltaics World Conference, to be held in New Delhi from 21 to 23 October.

“It is difficult to estimate but it should be upwards of 5-gigawatts in the next 3-4 years. It depends on state's enthusiasm, ability to quickly notify a feed-in tariff,” Mr Sarangi said.

Agrivoltaics is the practice of keeping agricultural land in its primary use while also generating solar photovoltaic power on it, so that the same field produces both a crop and electricity.

The constraint Mr Sarangi identified is tariff policy rather than technology. “Once they (the states) are ready with feed-in tariffs. It would provide certainty to the farmer-producers organisations and cooperatives to make the investment decision. If states act quickly then 5-gigawatts plus should not be an issue,” he explained.

He added that the ministry had observed enthusiasm from state governments as well, and that several states, among them Odisha, Maharashtra and Madhya Pradesh, had conducted their own pilot projects for agrivoltaics.

Central support is also being prepared. “We are planning for a central sector scheme which will support it (agrivoltaics). Probably we will make it a part of one of our existing schemes as and when those schemes are getting revised,” Mr Sarangi said. “On that we are working with the Finance Ministry on how this could be done and how states could be incentivised to do different kinds of agrivoltaic models.”

A feed-in tariff is a guaranteed price paid for electricity fed into the grid, and it is notified by individual states. Until one is notified, a farmer-producer organisation or cooperative weighing an investment has no price to plan against.

The forecast therefore rests on two quantities. One is the speed at which states publish tariffs, which is a measurable administrative process with dates attached to it. The other is enthusiasm.

This newspaper notes that enthusiasm has now been given a load-bearing role in a national capacity projection, and that it is the variable the projection is most sensitive to.

The implications for planning are considerable. If five gigawatts depends on state enthusiasm, then enthusiasm has a unit, and the unit is the gigawatt. A moderately keen state is worth some number of megawatts. A reluctant one subtracts them.

Our analysts have begun the necessary conversions. Odisha, Maharashtra and Madhya Pradesh have each run pilot projects, which under this framework is the observable signature of enthusiasm, and the ministry has confirmed that it has observed it.

The Department of Unnecessary Research raises only the question of measurement. A feed-in tariff is notified on a date and can be checked in a gazette. Enthusiasm is not notified, carries no date, and cannot be read off anything.

The Secretary was careful throughout, and said so at the outset: the figure is difficult to estimate. The estimate is five gigawatts.

THE FORECAST AND ITS TWO CONDITIONSQUESTIONABLE ANALYTICS
1005 GW in 3-4 years
60Tariffs notified
60State enthusiasm
Illustrative newsroom graphic, normalised 0-100 for display. The ministry gave a figure for the capacity and no figure for either condition.
THE BORING FACT

Santosh Kumar Sarangi, Secretary at India's Union Ministry of New and Renewable Energy, told reporters that the country's agrivoltaic capacity should be upwards of five gigawatts in the next three to four years, while saying it is difficult to estimate and that the outcome depends on state enthusiasm and the speed at which states notify feed-in tariffs.

Source: The Hindu
OUR PROFESSIONAL CONCLUSION

Because the ministry's five-gigawatt projection depends on state enthusiasm, enthusiasm is now a quantity measured in gigawatts, and the only condition in the forecast that cannot be checked is the one the forecast turns on.

REALITY CHECK · CATEGORY ERROR

Unfortunately, there's a small problem.

Naming a soft condition alongside a hard one does not convert it into a measurable input: “enthusiasm” here is shorthand for whether state governments choose to act, and a forecast that says so is being candid about its own uncertainty rather than quantifying a feeling.

THE BS DETECTOR

Where did reality end?

Tap the paragraph where this story stopped being true. Then see where everyone else bailed.

 

READER CREDULITY METER

Did you believe this story before the twist?

Be the first reader to answer.