TODAY IN NUMBERS
WEATHER · SATIRE · SELECTIVE BASELINE

Pacific Sets Records on an Index Built to Remove the Warming, Whose Own History Begins in 2008

Australia's Bureau of Meteorology says weekly sea-surface temperatures in the central Pacific are the highest on record, weeks before El Nino's expected peak. Parts of the tropical Pacific have passed 30C for the first time.

Editorial cartoon illustration: On the deck of a research vessel in a flat calm tropical sea, two oceanographers in sun hats haul a dripping sensor buoy over the rail, squinting in hard sunlight. A third scientist stands a little apart holding a short wooden ruler up against the horizon. A rolled measuring tape lies at their feet beside a bucket of seawater.
Editorial illustration by The Questionable Times. Based on the verified event; scene is illustrative.

El Nino has continued to strengthen to what some scientists are calling "unprecedented levels", weeks before its expected peak in December, with several key measures now in record territory, BBC Weather reports.

In its latest update, Australia's Bureau of Meteorology said average weekly sea-surface temperatures in the central Pacific have reached their highest level on record. That follows the declaration in September of a new record for daily sea-surface temperatures in the central-eastern Pacific, exceeding the previous mark set during the very strong El Nino of 2015.

Temperatures above 30C have also been recorded for the first time in parts of the tropical Pacific, alongside record sea-surface temperature anomalies and exceptional subsurface warmth. The measurements come from the stretch of the equatorial Pacific used to monitor El Nino.

El Nino is a naturally occurring pattern that arrives every two to seven years and tends to last about a year. The Pacific is also warming because of human-induced climate change, and that background warming is starting to mask the strength of the natural warming during an El Nino event.

To remove the extra signal, Australian and US official forecasters are now using a Relative Ocean El Nino Index, or RONI, which is intended to allow better comparison with historical events. The Bureau's average weekly data on that measure goes back only to 2008, and now exceeds the levels seen in the record-breaking December of 2015.

"We are currently witnessing an El Nino event that is unprecedented in the historical record," Dr Zeke Hausfather, a climate scientist at Berkeley Earth, told the BBC.

The warmth now extends well beyond the tropical region normally used to monitor the pattern. Comparisons with the major events of 1972-73, 1982-83, 1997-98 and 2015-16 show much more widespread ocean warmth across the Pacific and into the Gulf of Mexico. "The strength of El Nino this year is spilling out of the traditional El Nino region," Hausfather said.

The World Meteorological Organization says there is currently no evidence that climate change is making El Nino events stronger or more frequent, though it remains an active area of research. What is clearer is that El Nino releases additional heat from the oceans into the atmosphere, and that is expected to help make 2026 one of the warmest years on record, with unusually high global temperatures likely to continue into 2027.

The instrument at the centre of this deserves a paragraph of its own. Because the ocean is warming for reasons that are not El Nino, forecasters have adopted an index that subtracts the warming that is not El Nino, so that El Nino can be compared with earlier El Ninos.

This newspaper regards the solution as elegant. The Pacific is now setting records on a measure specifically designed not to notice the thing making it warmer, and the records are being set weeks early.

The yardstick's own biography should also be entered into the record. The Bureau's weekly figures on this index begin in 2008, which makes the historical record in which the event is unprecedented eighteen years long.

The Department of Unnecessary Research notes the remaining difficulty, which is geographical. The warmth has spread outside the box used to define El Nino, so a share of the present event is now, strictly speaking, not El Nino at all.

The water on either side of that boundary is the same temperature. Only the index can tell them apart.

THE EVENTS BEING COMPAREDQUESTIONABLE ANALYTICS
201972-73
401982-83
601997-98
802015-16
1002026-27
Illustrative newsroom graphic. The bars mark the major El Nino events compared in the report, in order of occurrence; they are not measured temperature anomalies.
THE BORING FACT

Australia's Bureau of Meteorology says average weekly sea-surface temperatures in the central Pacific have reached their highest level on record, weeks before El Nino's expected December peak, and temperatures above 30C have been recorded for the first time in parts of the tropical Pacific. Forecasters now use a Relative Ocean El Nino Index, whose weekly data goes back only to 2008.

Source: BBC Weather
OUR PROFESSIONAL CONCLUSION

Because the index subtracts background ocean warming and its weekly record starts in 2008, an event can be called unprecedented in a historical record eighteen years long, while the warmth outside the monitoring box is formally not El Nino.

REALITY CHECK · SELECTIVE BASELINE

Unfortunately, there's a small problem.

RONI exists so that a natural oscillation can be compared across decades without the long-term warming trend swamping it; using it does not deny that warming, and the record claims rest on several independent measures, not one index. Monitoring boundaries are definitions for tracking a pattern, not statements about where the ocean is warm.

THE BS DETECTOR

Where did reality end?

Tap the paragraph where this story stopped being true. Then see where everyone else bailed.

 

READER CREDULITY METER

Did you believe this story before the twist?

Be the first reader to answer.